Most dentists are suicidal
Frequency of suicides among doctors and dentists in Upper Bavaria
A survey in Upper Bavaria (population 3.3 million) identified 119 suicides committed by medical practitioners (67 men and 27 women) and dental practitioners (19 men and 6 women) during the 16-year period 1963–1978. All suicides were traced, using the records of the Bavarian Boards of Physicians and Dentists and the files of the public prosecutors' offices. The suicide rate for male doctors was 1.6 times that for all male adults over 25 years of age in Upper Bavaria. The rate for women doctors was 3.0 times, for male dentists 1.3 times (not significantly raised), and for female dentists 2.9 times the corresponding rates for the male and female adult populations. - In all four subgroups the suicide rate was higher for persons living in surrounding rural or semirural areas than for those living in Munich, the state capital. In 59% of cases, suicide was committed by self-poisoning. Male doctors tended to commit suicide below the age of 55, male dentists above that age and female doctors and dentists between the ages of 45 and 65. Practitioners who had moved to Upper Bavaria were somewhat more likely to commit suicide than those born in the area . Suicide rates were much increased among those who were divorced, widowed or living alone, as compared with married persons. In many instances of an intact family life had never existed, had broken down shortly before the suicide, or was threatened with collapse (by fatal illness, divorce or separation). The suicide rate was high among persons who had no children or whose children had left home. Of those persons who were still of working age, 69.5% were active in their professions and a further 11.5% were in other forms of employment. Before their death, 15.8% had been ill or otherwise unable to work for some months and 55.5% were known to have had psychiatric treatment in the past (in 17.6% up to the week preceding suicide), while 41.2% had been in psychiatric inpatient care and 37.8% had previously attempted suicide. The data are discussed in relation to the findings of comparable studies in other countries.
In the period from 1.1. 1963–31.12. In 1978 there were 67 suicides by doctors, 27 suicides by women doctors, 19 suicides by dentists and 6 suicides by female doctors in Upper Bavaria. This suicide could be comprehensively based on the documents of Bayer. State Medical Association and Dental Association can be found and evaluated on all deceased doctors and dentists, as well as on the basis of the public prosecutor's investigation reports. The number of suicides among the doctors is 1.6 times, among the women doctors 3.0 times, among the dentists 2.9 times significant, with the dentists 1.3 times not significantly higher than the suicides among men over 25 years of age or female population of Upper Bavaria. All four groups show a lower number of suicides in the city of Munich than in Upper Bavaria without Munich. The most common suicide method used was medication. Most of the doctors died under the age of 55, the dentists over the age of 55 and the doctors between the ages of 45 and 65 as a result of suicide. The majority come from other regions with regard to their place of birth. An intact family life with a spouse and / or parents has either never existed, has recently broken up or is in danger of falling apart (death, divorce or separation). You are childless or the children no longer live in the household. You hardly ever work as a doctor, you are more likely to be retired, unemployed, have been sick for months or have been outside your job. They are actually or imagined seriously somatically ill or chronically disabled, especially mentally ill, especially depressed and / or addicted, have already attempted suicide and have already received psychiatric treatment on an outpatient or inpatient basis.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalized during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalized during checkout.
Bämayr A (1983) About the suicide of 119 doctors and dentists in Upper Bavaria from 1963 to 1978. Diss med Munich
Blachly PH, Disher W, Roduner G (1968) Suicide by physicians. Bull Suicidology: 1-18
Böcker F (1973) Suicides and attempted suicide. Thieme, Stuttgart
Bonk K (1973) Suicide and alcohol with special consideration of the alcoholic influence at the time of the crime. Diss med Cologne
Brown C (1971) Suicide. Goldmann, Munich
Bureau of Economic Research and Statistics (1975) Mortality of dentists, 1868-1972. JADA 90: 195-198
Craig AG, Pitts FN (1968) Suicide by physicians. Dis Nerv Syst 29: 763-772
Dean G (1969) The causes of death of South African doctors and dentists. S Af Med J 43: 495-500
De Hart C (1974) Suicide by physicians. J Maine Med Assoc 65 (2): 32-33
De Sole DE, Singer P, Aronson S (1969) Suicide and role strain among physicians. Int J Soc Psychiatry 15: 294-301
Enders F (1969) Causes of Doctors' Death in Hamburg from 1945–1967. Diss med Hamburg
Feuerlein W (1973) Suicide and Attempted Suicide. Med Klin 68: 1717-1721
Feuerlein W (1976) Addiction and the act of suicide. In: Ringel E (Ed) Addiction and Suizid, Lambertus, Freiburg
Her Majesty Stationery Office (1971) Occupational mortality, England and Wales 1961. The registrar general's decennial supplement, HMSO, London
Koller S (1970) Number, structure and demand for young doctors, Federal Ministry for Youth, Family and Health, Federal Printing Office
Lindhardt M, Frandsen E, Hamtoft E, Mosbech J (1963) Causes of death among the medical profession in Denmark. Danish Med Bull 10: 59-64
Murray RM (1978) The health of doctors: a review. J Roy Coll Phycns 12 (5): 403-415
Parkes CM (1974) Isolation. The life crisis when a partner is lost. Rowohlt, Reinbek near Hamburg
Pitts FN, Schuller AB, Rich CL, Pitts AF (1979) Suicide among U.S. women physicians, 1967-1972. Am J Psychiatry 136 (5): 694-696
Pohlmeier H (1978) Suicide and Suicide Prevention. Urban & Schwarzenberg. Munich-Vienna-Baltimore
Rich CL, Pitts FN (1979) Suicide by male physicians during a five-year period. Am J Psychiatry 136 (8): 1089-1090
Ringel E (1961) New Studies on the Suicide Problem. Hollinek brothers, Vienna
Rose KD, Rosow I (1973) Physicians who kill themselves. Arch Gen Psychiatry 29: 800-805
Sakinofsky I (1980) Suicide in doctors and their Wives. Br Med J 281: 386-387
Scarott DM (1978) Death rates of dentists. Br Dent J 145 (8): 245-246
Federal Statistical Office Wiesbaden (1956) Special contribution: Occupation and cause of death. Population and Culture, Series A, Series 7, Health Care (results of a special census 1955). Kohlhammer, Stuttgart Mainz
Stengel E (1969) Suicide and Attempted Suicide. Fisherman. Frankfurt / M.
Steppacher RC, Mausner JS (1974) Suicide in male and female physicians. JAMA 228 (3): 323-328
Welner A, Marten S, Wochnick E, Davis MA, Fishman R, Clayton PJ (1979) Psychiatric disorders among professional women. Arch Gen Psychiatry 36: 169-173
Max Planck Institute for Psychiatry, Munich
A. Bämayr & W. Feuerlein
About this article
Cite this article
Bämayr, A., Feuerlein, W. Frequency of suicides among doctors and dentists in Upper Bavaria. Soc Psychiatry21, 39-48 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00585321
- Should all Canadians leave China
- Napoleon Bonaparte was a populist
- What makes Batman unique from other superheroes
- What is a bad winner
- Who did Indira Gandhi marry
- How do you describe a circus
- What's so bad about Christianity
- Rahul Gandhi is a good, honest politician
- What notoriety was your schoolmate
- Why do orchestras tune into the oboe?
- Is philosophy a religion
- How can I identify fake USD
- What are the most promising technological breakthroughs
- How did you celebrate Mahashivratri
- What are the steps in locating
- Is the Vedic religion monotheistic
- Is it difficult to start a charity?
- Are Vietnamese cowards
- Why is Perth so boring
- Makes American Spirit Menthol Lights 100s
- Are Trump's tariffs great
- How to make a chain mail bracelet
- Was Katrina the hottest Indian actress ever
- What are some fun debate topics
- In aviation what is an accelerated stall
- What is the big American dream
- Why does Rahul Gandhi behave immaturely?
- Is my best friend a true friend
- Why are changes in the constitution necessary?
- You will need reading glasses for astigmatism
- Is Donald Rump the anti-Trump Christ
- What are the options to stay in Bandhavgarh
- Sunflowers reduce air pollution
- Scientologists go to church